Bradley C. Gregory, «Vice and Virtue in the Moral Vision of the Latin of Sirach.», Vol. 97 (2016) 41-61
Beginning in the Second Temple period some Jewish literature begins to reflect an increased influence from Hellenistic conceptions of virtue and vice. This paper analyzes the expansions and alterations found in the Latin version of Ben Sira to show how the vices of pride, desire, and avarice are elevated in importance and integrated into the larger contours of the moral theology of the book. Their content, amount, and distribution suggest that their piecemeal production arose from attempts to integrate the virtue/vice thinking prominent in late antiquity into the teaching already found in the Book of Sirach.
ViCe AnD VirTue 49
placens Deo et contine et congrega cor tuum in sanctitate eius et tris-
titiam longe expelle a te) 29. Here, the idea of self-deception is shifted
to self-pity and modified with the concepts of pleasing God and self-
control. Likewise, the Greek’s reference to comfort is reoriented
towards the holiness of self-discipline 30.
in the passage discussed above in relation to Grii, the Latin also
contains the title “On Temperance of the Soul” (de continentia ani-
mae) 31 prior to 18,30 and the elaboration of 19,3 in manuscript 743
and Clement of Alexandria. The bicolon found in 19,5b-6a is not
found in the Latin, but this may be because it was missing from the
Latin’s Vorlage. However, a few verses earlier in 19,2 the Latin adds
to the statement that wine and women lead the intelligent astray a
further warning that they will even test the prudent (+ et arguent [or
arguet] sensatos) 32.
The most significant additions related to desire and self-control are
clustered in passages concerning sexual morality and the consumption
of wine. On the issue of sexual morality there are two passages with
clusters of additions in the Latin. First, in 9,1-9 (1-12) Ben Sira
discusses caution in relating to various kinds of women. Although the
instruction opens with a reference to wives, the instruction quickly
transitions to a discussion of women who are off-limits for the male
student. in 9,4 the Latin makes the admonition more restrictive 33. The
advice to avoid spending time with a female performer is expanded to
a prohibition not to listen to her either (+ nec audias illam), presum-
ably because this could be the first step in a process of seduction 34. in
antiquity the potential seductiveness of a woman’s singing voice was
recognized by both Jews (b. Berachot 24a) and Greeks (note the myth
of the Sirens) 35. This heightening of a prohibition occurs in 9,6 as
29
Biblia Sacra iuxta latinam vulgatam versionem, XII, 280.
30
Other places where the Latin adds general notions of restraint and absten-
tion from sin are 3,3 (4) and 3,29 (31-32). These are the only three instances of
self-control listed in keArnS, Expanded Text, 75.
31
Z lacks this title. See THieLe, Sirach, 530.
32
D: et arguunt sensatos. m lacks this addition. See THieLe, Sirach, 539.
regarding this addition, compare Theognis 499-502.
33
Similarly, in 9,9 (12) the warning against dining with another man’s wife
is expanded to prohibit reclining with her, but this addition is also found
in Clement of Alexandria, and so it likely reflects an expansion already in the
Latin’s Greek Vorlage. See ZieGLer, Sirach, 166.
34
So also D. See THieLe, Sirach, 341.
35
my thanks to Gary Anderson for drawing my attention to this motif.