Joost Smit Sibinga, «From Anointing to Arrest. Some Observations on the Composition of Mark 14:1-52», Vol. 23 (2010) 3-35
The article investigates the composition of Mark 14:1-52, in particular the words of Jesus, who speaks 14 times, including the four "Amen-words". The analysis is based mainly on the number of syllabes but also on the number of words used in the text. It reveals an ingenious design of considerable refinement and complexity. Mark"s composition method appears to be determined by a remarkable sense of order and technical precision and by a high degree of professional literary skill.
From Anointing to Arrest. Some Observations on the Composition of Mark... 5
times we find the formula ‘Truly, I say to you ..’, a rare and unprecedented
usage, it seems, which in the New Testament is confined to the words of
Jesus.9 Among these four ‘Amen-sayings’10, marked (a) - (d) in our Chart
1, (a) and (c) form the conclusion of a longer speech. For that reason
the data concerning the earlier part, here called ‘Annex’, are presented
first, those of the Ἀμήν-sayings follow. In the two columns of the Chart
marked ‘incipit aliter’ one finds the words of Jesus not introduced by the
Ἀμήν-formula. The far right column states the sum-total in both classes,
with and without ‘Amen’. The sign | designates the addition of numbers
in the column above. In the far-left column, concisely marking the course
of the Gospel story in Mark 14, ‘The Lord’s Supper’ is short for ‘The
Institution of The Lord’s Supper’; in v. 27 we call «πάντες σκανδαλισθή
σεσθε» v. 27b.
3. The Charts mainly state the number of syllables used. On the whole,
the count of syllables is without problems. Οὐαί in Mark 14:21 is counted
as one syllable, as are the Hebrew, Syriac and Latin equivalents.11
4. Mark used both the number of words (w.) and of syllables (s.) in
structuring the text of his gospel. Whoever is not familiar with this aspect
of the gospel can study it and find it illustrated in, e.g., Mark 4:3-8: 196 s.
in 98 w. In the Passion Narrative it can be documented in Mark 14:1-2a:
17 + 29 + 4 = 50 s. in 10 + 13 + 2 = 25 w.; or Mark 14:24b-25: 74 s. in 37
words. In Mark 14:46 the number of syllables is 11 + 7 = 18 s., the number
of words is 6 + 3 = 9. For Mark 14:48-49 N(arrative) and D(iscourse) one
counts 12 + 56 = 68 s. in 6 + 28 = 34 words. Mark 14:69-71 was, I suggest,
composed on the ‘Golden Ratio’: 19 + 31 = 50 words use 38 + 62 = 100
syllables.12 In all these cases one finds a ratio of two syllables to one word.
Our present investigation deals with the words spoken by Jesus in Mark
14:1-52 and their size, mainly, but not only, as measured in syllables. The
evidence is presented in the following Chart.
9
In the Testament of Abraham, Recension A, 8 (ed. M.R. James, 1892, p. 8519) and 20
(p. 10223) God and Death are the speakers. Cf. J. Jeremias, Neutestamentliche Theologie, I
(1971), Gütersloh: Mohn, ³1979, p. 44-45.
10
In the series of thirteen occurrences in Mark these are ## 10-13.
11
For comparison one might, e.g., study the fragment of a letter of Dionysios of Corinth
to the Romans, quoted by Eusebius, Historia Ecclesiastica 4. 23.12 (E. Schwartz, editio
minor, (1914), Berlin: Akademie-Verlag, ⁵1952, p. 160, l. 13-17). The size is 19 + 38 + 43 =
100 syllables, when in l. 15 οὐαί is counted as one syllable.
12
It is worthwhile to compare a pasage from Andocides, De mysteriis 7: Ὁπότ’ οὖν ...
ἀπολογουμένου (G. Daleyda, Paris: Les Belles Lettres, 1930, p. 19): 35 + 26 + 39 = 61 + 39
= 100 syllables in 16 + 15 + 19 = 31 + 19 = 50 words. This speech is dated to 399 B.C. An
example from Paul: in Rom 8:15-16, 17 he uses 62 + 38 = 100 s. in 29 + 16 = 45 words.