Terrance Callan, «Partenoi in Corinth: 1 Cor 7,25-40», Vol. 97 (2016) 264-286
Interpreters differ significantly regarding the identity of the 'partenoi' discussed in 1 Cor 7,25-40. There is some uncertainty about whether they are men and women, or only women. And those who understand them as only women differ as to whether they are betrothed women, unmarried daughters, spouses in spiritual marriages, or young widows who are possible candidates for levirate marriage. I argue that the 'partenoi' are only women, and that they are unmarried daughters of Corinthian Christians. The argument is based mainly on usage of 'partenos' in literature written before, and at approximately the same time as, 1 Corinthians. In addition i offer an interpretation of 1 Cor 7,25-40, especially of vv. 36-38, that supports understanding the word as designating young, unmarried daughters.
266 terraNCe CallaN
dionysius of Halicarnassus, Plutarch, and other writers frequently use
parqe,noj in speaking of the Vestal Virgins. For example, in Romulus
3.3 Plutarch refers to a priestess of Vesta, bound to live unmarried
(a;gamon) and a parqe,noj all her days 7. in addition to such passages, i
have found seventeen other passages that speak of a woman’s being a
parqe,noj, either temporarily or permanently, for the sake of service to
a god or goddess. For example, diodorus Siculus (16.26.2) narrates
how in the past the priestess of apollo at delphi was a parqe,noj. after
one of them was carried away and violated, the parqe,noj was replaced
by an elderly woman of fifty dressed in the costume of a parqe,noj 8.
all together i have found ninety-six instances of this use of parqe,noj.
Few interpreters see the Corinthian parqe,noi as consecrated in
some special way, but there is more difference of opinion among inter-
preters regarding other aspects of their identity. there is first of all
some uncertainty about whether they are both men and women, or only
women 9. and those who understand them as only women differ as to
whether they are betrothed women, unmarried daughters, spouses in
spiritual marriages, or young widows who are possible candidates for
levirate marriage 10.
in what follows i will argue that the parqe,noi are only women, and
that they are unmarried daughters of Corinthian Christians. My argu-
ment will be based mainly on usage of parqe,noj in literature written
before, and at approximately the same time as, 1 Corinthians. this usage
indicates the most likely meaning of the word as used in 1 Corinthians.
obviously, however, this evidence does not exclude the possibility that
the word is being used in some unusual way in 1 Corinthians. therefore,
7
See appendix a.
8
other references to parqe,noi in service to a god or goddess are found in eu-
ripides, The Trojan Women 41, 253; Pausanias, 2.10.4; 2.33.2; 3.16.1; 3.18.4;
7.18.12; 7.19.1; 7.19.2 (twice); 7.22.8; 7.26.5; 8.5.12; 8.13.5; 9.27.6; Cassius dio,
67.15.1.
9
those who argue that the parqe,noi are both men and women include e.-B.
allo, Saint Paul Première Épître aux Corinthiens (etB; Paris 1956) 177;
W.F. orr – J.a. WaltHer, 1 Corinthians (aB 32; Garden City, NY 1976) 220;
ColliNS, First Corinthians, 288; a.C. tHiSeltoN, The First Epistle to the Corinthians.
a Commentary on the Greek text (New international Greek testament Commen-
tary; Grand rapids, Mi – Cambridge uK – Carlisle 2000) 570-571; J.a. FitzMYer,
First Corinthians (anchor Yale Bible 32; New Haven, Ct 2008) 314; a.r. GueN-
tHer, “one Woman or two? 1 Corinthians 7:34”, Bulletin for Biblical Research
12 (2002) 39.
10
tHiSeltoN (First Epistle to the Corinthians, 595-597) gives rather extensive
lists of those who have advocated each of these views.