Iwan M. Whiteley, «Zechariah, Reference and the Structure of Revelation 6-8:1», Vol. 23 (2010) 93-108
This article argues that Rev 6-8:1 is structured on Zech 1-2. It first undertakes a survey of interpretational difficulties that exist in Revelation 6-8:1. It contains a survey of commentators’ views regarding the unit of discourse. Then there is a demonstration that structuring Rev 6-8:1 on Zech 1-2 solves many of the difficulties, notably the rapid shift in scenes in the text. An exploration of the issue of reference ensues with the intention of suggesting that one should import information from Zech 1-2 into Revelation. Consequently, there is an investigation into the meaning of Zech 1-2. Finally, information from this book is imported into Rev 6-8:1.
98 Iwan M. Whiteley
Zechariah 1-2 Revelation 6-8:1
1:8-10 Four horses, ‘They are the ones the 1st seal: 1st horse
LORD has sent to go throughout the earth.’ 2nd seal: 2nd horse
3rd seal: 3rd horse
1:11-12 ‘How long will you withhold mercy 4th seal: 4th horse
from Jerusalem?’ 5th seal: ‘How Long?’
1:13-17 ‘I am very angry with the nations that 6th seal: ‘Hide us from the face of Him who
feel secure.’ sits on the throne.’
2:1-2 The measuring of Jerusalem 7:1-8 The measuring of the people of God
2:3-4 ‘Jerusalem will be a city without walls 7:9 People without number
because of the great number of livestock
and men in it.’
2:10 Call to praise God 7:10-12 People praise God
2:13 ‘Be silent before the Lord, all mankind, 7th seal: Silence in heaven for half an hour
because He has roused Himself from His
holy dwelling.’
Rogers noticed certain aspects of this structure.30 This proposal is
significant in that it explains what appear to be the radical shifts in
scenes in Rev 6-8:1. The four horsemen in Revelation introduce the reader
to John’s presupposition pool, namely he is establishing a relationship
between his text and Zech 1. Therefore, as the reader continues through
the rest of Rev 6, Zechariah is still in their mind. When the fifth seal
is opened and the cry “How long?” goes out, the reader explores the
possibility that John is continuing to refer to Zechariah. The sixth seal
does not frustrate this proposition and then the departure from the seal
structure in chapter 7 can only be explained in light of Zech 2. In both
passages, the people of God are either being or about to be counted as
if they could be restricted to a discrete number and in both passages
the reader is informed that the people of God will be without number.
Zechariah, like Revelation, appears to be contradictory because in 2:10,
the people are called to “shout and be glad” and yet in 2:13, all mankind
are called to be silent.
According to current approaches to the study of allusions in Revelation,
the language of chapter 7 appears to be too deviant from Zech 1-2 for
there to be an allusion. However, an investigation in the underlying flow
of Rev 6 may help in the solution of the issue. Jauhiainen provides an
30
R. Rogers, “An Exegetical Analysis of John’s use of Zechariah in the Book of Revela-
tion: The Impact and Transformation of Zechariah’s Text and Themes in the Apocalypse”,
(Ph.D diss., Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, 2002), 101; see also M. Jauhiainen,
The Use of Zechariah in Revelation (Tübingen 2005) 73.