Debbie Hunn, «Pleasing God or Pleasing People? Defending the Gospel in Galatians 1–2», Vol. 91 (2010) 24-49
Scholars agree that in Gal 1,13–2,21 Paul substantiates his gospel but disagree as to his method. The three common views: that Paul defends his apostolate, that he denies accusations, and that he functions as a paradigm conflict with the text. Instead, Paul sets up two categories in 1,10 — that of seeking to please people and that of seeking to please God — and defends his gospel by means of his Damascus experience together with his subsequent life motivation.
41
PLEASING GOD PLEASING PEOPLE ?
OR
his reputation as a gospel preacher reached believers who knew he
was not associating with the other apostles (1,22-23). Paul gives his
itinerary up to this point.
Paul’s testimony about his trip to Jerusalem has been called into
question as well because of the correspondence between Gal 1,18-19
and Acts 9,26-29. In both instances Paul goes from Damascus to
Jerusalem (Acts 9,22-26 ; Gal 1,17-18) ; and in both Paul then leaves
Jerusalem for the same area, with Acts 9,30 naming the cities,
Cesarea and Tarsus, and Gal 1,21 the regions, Syria and Cilicia.
Luke and Paul have different emphases: Luke focuses on the trouble
Paul stirs up (Acts 9,28-30) whereas Paul relates the brevity of his
visit and of his contact with Peter and James (Gal 1,18-19). The
difficulty is that Luke has Barnabas bring Paul to the apostles (Acts
9,27), and Paul denies seeing all but two of them. Although it might
be said that two apostles are still apostles, Luke did say “the
apostles †and not merely “some apostlesâ€. And although other
biblical writers could be a bit loose with their references by today’s
standards — Paul says Jesus appeared to Cephas then to the twelve
(1 Cor 1,5) at a time when there were only eleven apostles, and John
says Jesus appeared to “the disciples†when Thomas was absent
(John 20,19, 24) — two would hardly constitute a quorum. However,
it was valid in Luke’s time, as it often is in our own, to refer to the
leaders of a group as the group itself. For example, Pilate says in
John 19,35 that Jesus’ nation and the chief priests delivered Jesus to
him when it was the chief priests as the leaders of the nation,
together with at most a small portion of the populace, that actually
did so 45. As Gal 2,9 indicates, Peter, James, and John were the
leaders among the apostles. If Barnabas brought Paul to two of the
three leaders, Luke could correctly say that Barnabas brought Paul
to the apostles.
c) Conclusion: Galatians 1,11-12 via 1,10
As noted earlier, Paul constructs in 1,10 two mutually exclusive
but all inclusive categories: that of pleasing people and that of
pleasing God. By arguing that he kept his distance from Jerusalem
and the other apostles when he began preaching, Paul demonstrates
See Matt 26,14-15; 27,9 for another example. The “sons of Israel†in
45
27,9 were the chief priests in 26,14-15.