Debbie Hunn, «Pleasing God or Pleasing People? Defending the Gospel in Galatians 1–2», Vol. 91 (2010) 24-49
Scholars agree that in Gal 1,13–2,21 Paul substantiates his gospel but disagree as to his method. The three common views: that Paul defends his apostolate, that he denies accusations, and that he functions as a paradigm conflict with the text. Instead, Paul sets up two categories in 1,10 — that of seeking to please people and that of seeking to please God — and defends his gospel by means of his Damascus experience together with his subsequent life motivation.
38 DEBBIE HUNN
[Peter’s and Paul’s] two apostolic missions†38. However, the details
Paul includes — the three year gap, the brevity of the visit, and the
encounter with James — are irrelevant to concord between Peter and
Paul. Aletti, on the other hand, notes that Paul would have to bring
up his stay with Peter to counter the idea that he had been
catechized by the Jerusalem apostles. He finds Paul to emphasize
features that minimize the importance of the trip 39. Fifteen days in
Peter’s house, however, allows time for extensive deliberation on the
gospel. Furthermore, the incident is important: Paul’s brief
association with the Jerusalem apostles — of whom he met only two
— is evidence that he did not ingratiate himself with them or seek to
rise through their ranks.
In 1,21 Paul continues a tight account of his movements. Here
epeita “ then †in 1,21 introduces Paul’s next move because he
¶
emphasizes leaving Jerusalem for Gentile lands. As Paul’s journey
to Arabia and Damascus in 1,17b says first of all that he was not in
Jerusalem (1,17a), so his departure to Cilicia and Syria in 1,21 says
that he left Jewish territory when he left Jerusalem. His explicit
statement in vv. 22-23 that the Judean Christians knew him by
reputation but not by face again points up his lack of time in
Judea 40. Citing witnesses that he evangelized among the Gentiles
while hardly contacting Jerusalem completes his proof that he did
not advance himself among the apostles, at least up to this point 41.
Paul thus shows that he disregarded status in human circles but
strove instead to glorify God (v. 24). Verses 13-24 therefore
establish v. 10 that Paul no longer seeks to please people but God,
and v. 10 gives the grounds for vv. 11-12 that his gospel is from God.
Unlike the other theories of how Paul substantiates his gospel, this
J. PETERSON, “The Extent of Christian Theological Diversity: Pauline
38
Evidence â€, Restoration Quarterly 47 (2005) 7.
ALETTI, “Galates 1–2â€, 314-315.
39
Since Luke records that Paul had persecuted Jewish Christians
40
(Acts 8,1-4), how could the Judeans not know his face? Paul’s point is that they
had not seen him as a preacher of the gospel. Now when Paul visited Jerusalem
the first time after his conversion, Luke records that he did preach (Acts 9,26-
28) ; but fifteen days (Gal 1,18) of preaching would allow only a small number
of Christians in Judea to see him. For other viewpoints, see DUNN, Galatians,
81; LONGENECKER, Galatians, 41.
That Judaizers visited Paul’s churches in Acts 15,1 implies also that the
41
Jewish Christians knew Paul’s gospel was law free.