Isabel Cranz, «Ritual Elements in Zechariah's Vision of the Woman in the Ephah», Vol. 96 (2015) 586-598
This paper proposes a conceptual link between Zechariah's vision of the woman in the ephah (Zech 5,5-11) and Assyro-Babylonian exorcisms utilizing figurines. My comparison focuses on the integration of ritual elements in Zech 5,5-11. This analysis highlights the modifications that the ritual elements underwent before they could function as an integral part of a prophetic vision. The analysis of Zech 5,5-11 against the backdrop of Assyro-Babylonian exorcisms sheds new light on the manner in which the prophetic author(s) employed ritual material in his exemplification of sin and atonement.
06_An_Cranz_586-598_coopia_586-598 10/12/15 10:35 Pagina 587
587 RITUAL ELEMENTS IN ZECHARIAH’S VISION OF THE WOMAN 587
that Zechariah’s vision presents the prophetic counterpart to priestly con-
ceptions of expiation and purgation 5. Finally, there are those that compare
Zechariah’s vision of the woman in the ephah to Hittite myths in which the
divine wrath is contained in clay vessels and stored at the bottom of the
ocean 6. In other words, biblicists have made ample use of comparative
material in attempts to identify the cultural inspirations and historical set-
tings of Zech 5,5-11. My analysis will employ a similar comparative
approach, but, instead of speculating about the potential origins of Zech
5,5-11, I will utilize Assyro-Babylonian exorcisms to shed light on the
manner in which the ritual elements are modified to play a meaningful role
in Zechariah’s vision-cycle. In contrast to the Hittite material, which
predates Zechariah by more than half a millennium, the Assyro-Babylonian
exorcisms are closer in time to the composition of the prophetic vision. In
either case, in my analysis I do not take the correlations between Zech 5,5-11
and the exorcisms to be any straightforward indication of direct influence
or dependence. Instead the similarities are viewed as resulting from a
shared cultural ethos. Comparing and contrasting Zechariah’s vision to
Assyro-Babylonian exorcisms can reveal how the prophetic author avails
himself of ritual elements which he then appropriates to fit his agenda. My
comparison unfolds in three steps: First the Assyro-Babylonian compara-
tive material and its rationale will be introduced. This is followed by an
examination of the similarities between Zechariah’s vision and the manipu-
Zach. 5,5-11 à la lumière de la littérature hittite”, RHR 187 (1975) 137-145,
here 143-144; C. JEREMIAS, Die Nachtgesichte des Sacharja. Untersuchungen
zu ihrer Stellung im Zusammenhang der Visionsberichte im Alten Testament
und zu ihrem Bildmaterial (FRLANT 117; Göttingen 1977) 196-197; C.L.
MEYERS – E.M. MYERS, Haggai, Zechariah 1–8. A New Translation with In-
troduction and Commentary (AB 25B; New York 1987) 313-314; M. FLOYD
“The Evil in the Ephah: Reading Zechariah 5:4-11 in Its Literary Context”,
CBQ 58 (1996) 51-68, here 62; C. UEHLINGER, “Figurative Policy, Propa-
ganda und Prophetie”, Congress Volume Cambridge 1995 (ed. J. EMERTON)
(SVT 66; Leiden 1997) 297-349, here 345-347.
5
Cf. C. KÖRTING, “Sach 5,5-11 – Die Unrechtmäßigkeit wird an ihren
Platz verwiesen”, Bib 87 (2006) 477-492, here 486-487.
6
For scholars who detect Hittite influence in this vision, see H. HOFFNER,
“Hittite Tarpiš and the Hebrew Teraphim”, JNES 27 (1968) 61-68, here 66;
D. P. WRIGHT, The Disposal of Impurity. Elimination Rites in the Bible and
in Hittite and Mesopotamian Literature (SBLDS 101; Atlanta, GA 1986) 273;
M. DELCOR, “La vision de la femme dans l’épha de Zach. 5,5-11 à lumière
de la literature Hittite”, RHR 187 (1975) 137-145 and V. HAAS, “Ein hurriti-
scher Blutritus und die Deponierung der Ritual Rückstände nach hethitischen
Quellen”, Religionsgeschichtliche Beziehungen zwischen Kleinasien, Nordsyrien
und dem Alten Testament. Internationales Symposium Hamburg 17.-21. März
1990 (OBO 129; Göttingen 1990) 67-85.