C. John Collins, «Noah, Deucalion, and the New Testament», Vol. 93 (2012) 403-426
Jewish authors in the second Temple period, as well as early Christian authors after the New Testament, made apologetically-motivated connections between the biblical story of Noah and Gentile stories of the flood, including Greek stories involving deucalion — most notably Plato’s version. Analysis of the New Testament letters attributed to Peter indicates that these also allude to the Gentile flood stories, likely in order to enhance their readers’ sense of the reality of the biblical events.
05_Biblica_1_H_Collins_Layout 1 05/11/12 12:19 Pagina 422
422 C. JOHN COLLINS
In 2 Peter 3,5-6 we find similar indications that more factors than
the LXX lie behind the New Testament author’s presentation. In v. 5
he reminds us, “the earth was formed [or, put together, ]
out of water and through waterâ€. It is mysterious exactly what he
means by water as a material, but the term “formed†/ “put togetherâ€
( ) is not used in the LXX for the notion of divine creation
and preservation, though it does appear in Hellenistic philosophers
with this idea, as early as Plato (e.g., Timaeus, 31b, 32c; Republic,
530a). Apparently Second Temple Jewish and early Christian writers
adopted this term from the philosophers as a way of expressing bib-
lical ideas 40.
The use of in 2 Peter 3,5 raises the question of whether
the non-LXX in v. 6 (“the world that then existed … per-
ished ) alludes to a non-biblical source. The verb itself
is common enough in the New Testament, occurring about 90 times;
and in Genesis 18,28 the LXX uses it to render Hebrew “to de-
stroy or corruptâ€, which appears in the Hebrew of Genesis 6,11 etc.,
generally rendered in the LXX with cognates of “to corruptâ€.
However, the philosophical term is not the only evidence of non-bib-
lical allusions: in v. 9 the Lord is “not wishing that any should perish
, but that all should reach repentance
â€. The mention of repentance, in a context that is certainly
showing a parallel between the judgment in the great flood and the
judgment when the Lord comes, evokes Sibylline Oracles 1:129 (see
above, on 2 Peter 2,5 and Theophilus, 3.19).
The verb for the perishing of culture and persons in
the great flood occurs in Plato’s account (Laws, 677c), and also in
Wisdom 14,6 (see above). The collocation with , a term
also found in Plato, suggests that an account like that in Plato is the
ultimate source of the allusion in 2 Peter 3,5-6, whatever the medi-
ate source might be.
There are other possible allusions to Plato’s account, though these
are more faint. For example, 2 Peter 3,4 pictures the scoffers as say-
ing, “For ever since the fathers fell asleep, all things are continuing
as they were from the beginning of cre-
ationâ€. This is slightly reminiscent of Plato’s denial that “things had
For a fuller discussion, see C.J. COLLINS, “Colossians 1:17, ‘Hold to-
40
gether ’: A co-opted term with a punchâ€, forthcoming.