John Granger Cook, «1 Cor 9,5: The Women of the Apostles», Vol. 89 (2008) 352-368
The women of the apostles in 1 Cor 9,5 have posed a riddle in the history of interpretation. With few exceptions commentators over the last one hundred years have identified them as wives and dismissed the text in a few lines. Recent research on the role of women in early Christian mission has brought a fresh assessment, concluding that the women were missionary assistants to the apostles. This essay develops an extended argument to solidify the thesis using the history of interpretation, the nature of missionary partnerships in the Pauline epistles, semantics, some important parallels from the Greco-Roman world, and the nature of ancient households.
1 Cor 9,5: The Women of the Apostles (*)
The women of the apostles that Paul mentions in 1 Cor 9,5 could have
played an important role in the growth of earliest Christianity.
Although this claim has appeared elsewhere, I will develop an
extended argument to strengthen the position. Several old but still
present strands in the history of interpretation, Paul’s references to
missionary couples, his linguistic usage, and some similar marriages in
ancient Greco-Roman culture illuminate the probable function of the
women as missionary assistants of the apostles.
History of interpretation (or reception) does need an apologia pro
vita sua for modern scholars. Instead of moving immediately from
Paul’s text to modern research, a short detour through the past can
strengthen and enrich scholarly understanding of both the problems
and possibilities of the biblical material (1). In the case of 1 Cor 9,5 four
major questions have emerged. (1.) Did the women participate in the
mission? (2.) Did they follow the apostles to be instructed? (3.) Or
were they just for material support (2)? (4.) Were the women wives (3)?
The last question is related to the historical issue of Peter’s wife and
children (if any). Views on the celibacy of clerics have been closely
related to the last two questions (4). With the history of the text’s
reception as a resource, 1 Cor 9,5 becomes a rich source instead of a
text that the commentator glosses quickly.
Below I will briefly consider the question of Cephas’ identity,
discuss the text-critical evidence, and then look at the major strands in
the past understanding of the women and their marriages (or not) to the
(*) I read an earlier version of this paper at the 2006 SNTS meeting in
Aberdeen. I am grateful to Profs. Beverly Gaventa, Martin Hengel, Birger Olsson,
and many others for their critical comments. For bibliographical help, I thank
Profs. Jacques Gres-Gayer, Frank Matera, and Nelson Minnich.
(1) Cf the prolific use of interpretive history made by U. LUZ, Das Evangelium
nach Matthäus (EKK 1; Zurich 1985-2002). Dates below are primarily from
ODCC3.
(2) The New Jerusalem Bible’s note to 9,5 remarks that the wives were “for
the purpose of attending to their material welfareâ€.
(3) The New Jerusalem Bible, NAB, and New Revised Standard Version all
assume they were wives.
(4) For a convenient history cf P. DELHAYE, “Celibacy, Clerical, History ofâ€,
NCE II, 322-328.