John Kilgallen, «Acts 28,28 — Why?», Vol. 90 (2009) 176-187
The Isaian citation, used by Paul to describe his encounter with certain Jews in Rome, does not stand alone: it leads to a conclusion, a conclusion which is an imperative and an assurance. What is commanded is a knowledge of the plan of
God already in motion, a plan to offer salvation to Jews and Gentiles. As information for Jews of Rome, this final word of Paul is best understood as a motive for repentance; knowledge of the divine plan of God, which will succeed (28b), serves as an encouragement to Roman Jews to «turn and be healed by Me».
- «Luke 20,13 and i1swj» 2008 263-264
- «Luke wrote to Rome – a Suggestion» 2007 251-255
- «What Does It Mean to Say That There Are Additions in Luke 7,36-50?» 2005 529-535
- «Hostility to Paul in Pisidian Antioch (Acts 13,45) — Why?» 2003 1-15
- «Martha and Mary: Why at Luke 10,38-42?» 2003 554-561
- «‘With many other words’ (Acts 2,40): Theological Assumptions in Peter’s Pentecost Speech» 2002 71-87
- «The Obligation to Heal (Luke 13,10-17)» 2001 402-409
- «`The Apostles Whom He Chose because of the Holy Spirit'
A Suggestion Regarding Acts 1,2» 2000 414-417
- «The Strivings of the Flesh
(Galatians 5,17)» 1999 113-114
- «Jesus First Trial: Messiah and Son of God (Luke 22,66-71)» 1999 401-414
- «The Importance of the Redactor in Luke 18,9-14» 1998 69-75
- «Was Jesus Right to Eat with Sinners and Tax Collectors?» 2012 590-600
Acts 28,28 — Why? 183
no refusal to talk to Jews who had already visited with Paul in 28,13-
28 (31). Indeed, though clearly the final two verses serve as a closing
summary, they do not wholly intend a separation in thought from what
went before them, but rather suggest the possibility of continuity with
these prior verses.
Verse 28,28 is informational; certain Jewish leaders are to learn
what has happened in the past. However, we have said this knowledge
has a purpose beyond that of information: it is meant to spur them on
to repentance. But is it reasonable to expect that news of salvation
already sent to the Gentiles was thought to inspire, exhort repentance?
There are two examples to offer in which we can see an emphasis on
an urging to repentance, one from Paul and one from Jesus.
5. Acts 28,28 in relation to Rom 11 and the Gospel of Luke
Rom 9–11 is a somewhat tortuous reflection on the loss of Israel
and what its ultimate, final state will be before God. This reflection
involves the baptism of the Gentiles, a factor which was very visible in
Paul’s time and indeed an object of his dedicated preaching. In this
three-chapter discussion Paul offers a remark which is very much to
the heart of this present essay. At Rom 11,11-12 he says, “What I am
saying is this: Was this stumbling to lead to their final downfall? Out
of the question! On the contrary, their failure has brought salvation for
the gentiles, in order to stir them to envy†(32). This text strongly shows
that many years prior to the writing of Acts there had been placed in
the tradition the thought that the transgression of Israel should
eventually serve as a spur to Israel’s repentance and acceptance of
“this salvationâ€. It would not be surprising, then, to read in Acts a
continuation of this same kind of purpose following upon criticism of
Israel (33).
(31) FITZMYER, Acts, 797 affirms that pavnta" (Acts 28,30) “is almost certainly
to be understood as ‘all individuals’ (so DUPONT, “La conclusionâ€, 376-380;
SCHNEIDER, Apg 2.419-20; GNILKA, Verstockung, 154).†Granted that the fuller
phrase pavnta" tou;" eijsporeuomevnou" pro;" aujtovn can only be understood as
referring to individuals (Jew or Gentile), the above comment seems unnecessary,
unless it means to say that Luke is here admitting to an abandonment of Israel as
a people — an affirmation we do not find expressed in Acts 28.
(32) Cf. Rom 10,19: “I shall rouse you to jealousy with a non-people†(eij" to;
parazhlw'sai aujtouv").
(33) It is noteworthy that in Rom 11,8 “Scripture says: God gave them a spirit
of stupor, blind eyes and deaf ears†and in 11,10: “David says: Let their eyes be
darkened so that they may not seeâ€. Thus, not only does Paul speak of Israel’s