John Kilgallen, «Acts 28,28 — Why?», Vol. 90 (2009) 176-187
The Isaian citation, used by Paul to describe his encounter with certain Jews in Rome, does not stand alone: it leads to a conclusion, a conclusion which is an imperative and an assurance. What is commanded is a knowledge of the plan of
God already in motion, a plan to offer salvation to Jews and Gentiles. As information for Jews of Rome, this final word of Paul is best understood as a motive for repentance; knowledge of the divine plan of God, which will succeed (28b), serves as an encouragement to Roman Jews to «turn and be healed by Me».
- «Luke 20,13 and i1swj» 2008 263-264
- «Luke wrote to Rome – a Suggestion» 2007 251-255
- «What Does It Mean to Say That There Are Additions in Luke 7,36-50?» 2005 529-535
- «Hostility to Paul in Pisidian Antioch (Acts 13,45) — Why?» 2003 1-15
- «Martha and Mary: Why at Luke 10,38-42?» 2003 554-561
- «‘With many other words’ (Acts 2,40): Theological Assumptions in Peter’s Pentecost Speech» 2002 71-87
- «The Obligation to Heal (Luke 13,10-17)» 2001 402-409
- «`The Apostles Whom He Chose because of the Holy Spirit'
A Suggestion Regarding Acts 1,2» 2000 414-417
- «The Strivings of the Flesh
(Galatians 5,17)» 1999 113-114
- «Jesus First Trial: Messiah and Son of God (Luke 22,66-71)» 1999 401-414
- «The Importance of the Redactor in Luke 18,9-14» 1998 69-75
- «Was Jesus Right to Eat with Sinners and Tax Collectors?» 2012 590-600
182 John Kilgallen
Roman Jews, does not lead to a movement to the Gentiles; that
movement has already taken place, and without explanation. V. 28
means not to explain a Pauline decision of missionary tactic, but to
offer a description of state of soul. And how would that knowledge of
the past serve, if not as urging the Jews of Rome to repent?
4. Acts 28,28b — wording and emphasis
Verse 28 ends with the assurance: aujtoiv (26) kaiv (27) ajkouvsontai.
The position of the wording suggests emphasis somewhere in the
verse. Accepting the suggestion of NJB and NAB, that Luke is here
intending “also†(28), we see Paul implying a possible association of the
Jews with the Gentiles in a future acceptance of “this salvation from
Godâ€: “they too will listenâ€. But what purpose would this union of Jew
with Gentile serve in Paul’s address to his audience? Certainly it is not
to underline contrast, but serves to encourage the Jews to receive the
message of salvation. Paul here is not offering a spiteful condemnation
of Roman Jews; that type of thinking might be part of Acts 13,46 and
18,6 (29), but Acts 28,28, as we have said, is not simply a third text in
imitation of the two earlier texts of Acts 13 and 18 (30). Acts 28,28b,
then, can serve as part of the motivation Paul uses for a possible future
reception of the word of God among the Roman Jews.
Indeed, this understanding makes the connection with Acts 28,30
smooth. Paul here is depicted as speaking to “all who came to himâ€;
this notice is without distinction between Jew and Gentile, and offers
(26) That the subject of the verb in 28,28b is presumed from 28,28a is
argument that the two parts of v. 28 are tightly bound one to the other, and so
should be treated together, despite editorial semi-colons, hyphens and periods.
(27) This word has been variously understood and interpreted. A minimal
understanding is as a simple connective of the two sentences that make up the
verse; in this view, one either understands the word to mean: “and they will listenâ€
ASV, NIV, or “they will listen†(with the kaiv untranslated) ESV, NRS, RSV,
NJB, NAU. But the position of kaiv suggests that we have here a certain degree of
emphasis, so as to mean: “they will also listen†NJB, NAB.
(28) It is possible to understand kaiv as the second part of the terms of contrast,
the first part of which is implicit: “(you have rejected)… but they will listenâ€. This
seems a less likely interpretation.
(29) For a discussion of these verses within their broader contexts, cf. R.F.
O’TOOLE, “The Christian Mission and the Jews at the End of the Acts of the
Apostlesâ€, Biblical Exegesis in Progress (eds. J.-N. ALETTI – J.-L. SKA) (AnBib
176; Rome 2009) 387-388.
(30) These texts are clearly meant to underline Paul’s departure from certain
Jews and so to offer the faith to certain Gentiles.