Christian Stettler, «The 'Command of the Lord' in 1 Cor 14,37 – a Saying of Jesus?», Vol. 87 (2006) 42-51
In 1 Cor 14,37 Paul mentions a “command of the Lord”. The language Paul uses
indicates that he is not referring to his own apostolic authority but to a saying of
Jesus. The context in 1 Corinthians 12–14 makes clear that the principle he has in
mind is mutual love. Therefore he must be referring to the summary of the law
given by Jesus in the love commandment which Paul primarily interprets in the
sense of mutual love among Christians. Like John 13,34 he calls this commandment
a command of Jesus. Moreover, Paul knows a tradition similar to Matt 7,21-23.
The “Command of the Lord†in 1 Cor 14,37 45
Spirit for the benefit of the whole congregation (“for the common goodâ€); this
common benefit is the purpose of the spiritual gifts Paul is talking about in
chapters 12–14. Paul mentions this purpose again in 12,25: the members of
the church shall show “care for one anotherâ€. In chapter 14, this purpose is
expressed by the mutual “upbuilding†of the church (vv. 3-5.12.17) and the
mutual “benefit†(v. 6), now in relation to the congregational meeting:
whatever happens there has to contribute to the benefit and the upbuilding of
the church. The way spiritual gifts are exercised as well as the higher or lesser
value of individual gifts has to be measured by this standard. Among the
“greater†gifts which the Corinthians are to seek (12,31a) are the
interpretation of tongues (14,5.12) and prophecy (14,1.5.12.39), because
these build up the church, whereas tongues without interpretation do not serve
this purpose, but build up only the speakers themselves.
According to some commentators, “to build up†in chapter 14 denotes
edifying speech, since “upbuilding†is paralleled to “encouragement†and
“consolation†in 14,3. Furthermore, the reason prophecy, (words of) reve-
lation, (words of) knowledge, teaching and interpreted tongues are “edifyingâ€
is that they are ways of understandable speech which addresses the mind (vv.
3.6.9.15-16.19.24). But this does not mean that for Paul only these gifts of
speech serve for “edificationâ€, and not also the practical sprititual gifts(18).
Paul’s concentration on gifts of speech in chapter 14 has to do with the
situation in Corinth with which he is dealing: the Corinthian Christians
overemphasise the gift of tongues in congregational meetings because they
misunderstand the true purpose of worship. Paul opposes their misjudgement
by emphasising mutual “upbuilding†as the purpose of everything that
happens in communal worship. In church meetings it is mainly gifts of speech
that are exercised (cf. 1 Cor 14,26), and therefore in chapter 14 Paul addresses
only them, whereas the practical gifts are exercised more in the everyday life
of the church. Elsewhere Paul uses the language of “upbuilding†in con-
nection with everyday situations like the tensions between the strong and the
weak and the problem of food offered to idols (Rom 14,19; 15,2; 1 Cor 8,1;
10,23). Here the issue is offending others by behaviour, not so much by
speech. It follows that we cannot limit “upbuilding†to speech although
mutual “encouragement†is an important means of upbuilding the church.
Rather, for Paul “upbuilding†should characterise all Christian action and
speech. “Upbuilding†is therefore synonymous with other words which
characterise Christian behaviour in a general way (19): benefitting others
(sumfevrein 6,12; 10,23; 12,7, wjfelei'n 14,6) and seeking the good of others
(10,24). According to Rom 14,17 – 15,2, that which builds up is ethically
“goodâ€, that which does not is ethically “evilâ€, and “building up†is further
characterised by serving one another, carrying one another’s burdens and
pleasing one another, not oneself. Finally, according to 1 Cor 8,1
(18) Like healing, miracles, faith, leadership, helping, serving, giving and practical
compassion (1 Cor 12,9-10; 13,2-3; Rom 12,7-8). That in early Christian teaching an
explicit distinction could be made between gifts of speech and practical gifts is shown by 1
Pet 4,11.
(19) See I. KITZBERGER, Bau der Gemeinde. Das paulinische Wortfeld oijkodomhv /
(ejp)oikodomein (FZB 53; Würzburg 1986).
'