Bradley C. Gregory, «Vice and Virtue in the Moral Vision of the Latin of Sirach.», Vol. 97 (2016) 41-61
Beginning in the Second Temple period some Jewish literature begins to reflect an increased influence from Hellenistic conceptions of virtue and vice. This paper analyzes the expansions and alterations found in the Latin version of Ben Sira to show how the vices of pride, desire, and avarice are elevated in importance and integrated into the larger contours of the moral theology of the book. Their content, amount, and distribution suggest that their piecemeal production arose from attempts to integrate the virtue/vice thinking prominent in late antiquity into the teaching already found in the Book of Sirach.
ViCe AnD VirTue 61
in a larger pattern within the Latin version of heightening God’s om-
niscience and omnipotence. Complementing the emphasis on divine
punishment, the Latin version assures the reader that pride, desire, and
envy all entail the social punishment of shame and ignominy. The final
facet of the consequences of vice is seen in the assurance that lust,
drunkenness, and avarice are self-destructive in damaging either one’s
soul or the overall quality of one’s life. The damage that sin does to
the perpetrator’s own soul is a classic feature of virtue ethics, but it is
also found more widely in the expansions and alterations on a variety
of topics in the Latin version of Ben Sira (e.g. 14,4; 19,6; 20,8; 37,21-
22 [24-25]; cf. 18,33 [=Grii]) 76.
Therefore, considered synchronically, the Latin version of Ben
Sira differs from the Hebrew and Greek versions in a greater emphasis
on certain vices in ways that both elevate their importance and also in-
tegrate them into the larger contours of the moral theology of the
book. Their content, amount, and distribution suggest that their piece-
meal production arose through attempts to integrate the teaching
already found in the book of Ben Sira with the increasing importance
of virtue/vice thinking in late antiquity 77.
The Catholic university of America Bradley C. GreGOry
Washington D.C., 20064
u.S.A.
Summary
Beginning in the Second Temple period some Jewish literature begins to reflect
an increased influence from Hellenistic conceptions of virtue and vice. This paper
analyzes the expansions and alterations found in the Latin version of Ben Sira
to show how the vices of pride, desire, and avarice are elevated in importance
and integrated into the larger contours of the moral theology of the book. Their
content, amount, and distribution suggest that their piecemeal production arose
from attempts to integrate the virtue/vice thinking prominent in late antiquity into
the teaching already found in the Book of Sirach.
76
See r. DeVeTTere, Introduction to Virtue Ethics: insights of the Ancient
Greeks (Washington, D.C. 2002) 13-39.
77
my thanks to Jeremy Corley who kindly read and provided numerous
insightful comments on an earlier draft of this essay.