Joel S. Baden, «The Continuity of the Non-Priestly Narrative from Genesis to Exodus», Vol. 93 (2012) 161-186
The question of the continuity of the non-priestly narrative from the patriarchs to the exodus has been the center of much debate in recent pentateuchal scholarship. This paper presents as fully as possible, in the space allowed, one side of the argument, namely, that the non-priestly narrative is indeed continuous from Genesis through Exodus. Both methodological and textual arguments are brought in support of this claim, as well as some critiques of the alternative theory.
183
THE CONTINUITY OF THE NON-PRIESTLY NARRATIVE
spoke to you out of the fire [...] he declared to you the covenant[...]
since you saw no shape at Horeb out of the fire [...]â€. Later in the
chapter the same idea is expressed: “as the Lord your God did for
you in Egypt before your very eyes [...] from the heavens he let you
hear his voice†(Deut 4,34-36). And following directly on this iden-
tification of the current generation with that of the exodus, Moses
states: “Because he loved your fathers, he chose their heirs after
them; he himself, in his great might, led you out of Egyptâ€. If the ad-
dressees are the ones who came out of Egypt, as is clearly the case
here, then “your fathers†can refer only to the patriarchs. So too in
Deut 7,8: “It was because the Lord favored you and kept the oath he
made to your fathers that the Lord freed you with a mighty hand and
rescued you from the house of bondageâ€. Again, if Moses’s ad-
dressees were the ones whom God freed from Egypt, then the ref-
erence to “your fathersâ€, and the oath made to them, can refer only
to the patriarchs and the patriarchal promises. And so again in Deut
29,12: “to the end that he may establish you this day as his people
and be your God, as he promised you and as he swore to your fa-
thers, Abraham, Isaac, and Jacobâ€. Two promises are described here:
the promise to the generation of addressees, and the promise to their
ancestors, the patriarchs. Even if the names of the patriarchs were
not mentioned here, they are the only possible referent for “your fa-
thersâ€, since the first promise described in Deut 29,12, “to youâ€,
must refer to the generation of the exodus — the same generation
that is standing in the plains of Moab. This conclusion is only bol-
stered by the beginning of this Mosaic speech, in 29,1: “You have
seen all that the Lord did before your very eyes in the land of Egyptâ€.
For the majority of Deuteronomy, it is assumed that the generation
of the exodus did not die in the wilderness, but are the same gener-
ation that stands before Moses to receive the laws on the border of
Canaan. Their fathers to whom God promised the land, therefore,
can only be the patriarchs.
Additionally, although it is sometimes claimed that D refers only
to the promise of land, this is not true. Certainly the vast majority
of promise passages in D mention only the land, which is only sen-
sible, since virtually all of D centers on the impending Israelite pos-
session of the promised land. There are two, however, that refer to
the promise of increase directly. In Deut 1,11, Moses says, “May
the Lord, the God of your fathers, increase your numbers a thou-
sandfold, and bless you as he has promised youâ€. And in Deut
© Gregorian Biblical Press 2012 - Tutti i diritti riservati