Joel S. Baden, «The Continuity of the Non-Priestly Narrative from Genesis to Exodus», Vol. 93 (2012) 161-186
The question of the continuity of the non-priestly narrative from the patriarchs to the exodus has been the center of much debate in recent pentateuchal scholarship. This paper presents as fully as possible, in the space allowed, one side of the argument, namely, that the non-priestly narrative is indeed continuous from Genesis through Exodus. Both methodological and textual arguments are brought in support of this claim, as well as some critiques of the alternative theory.
179
THE CONTINUITY OF THE NON-PRIESTLY NARRATIVE
priestly text — make the best sense, therefore, as part of an inde-
pendent non-priestly text.
IV. Connections outside of P and non-P
A further challenge to the claim that P was the first to connect the
patriarchs and the exodus comes from texts outside of P and non-P.
There are a number of passages in the prophetic corpus that clearly
know both the patriarchs and the exodus, and at times explicitly link
the two into a single history. Since it is commonly claimed (rightly
or wrongly) that P is a post-exilic work, any pre-exilic or exilic
prophetic writings are particularly relevant to this discussion.
Hosea 12 contains numerous references to the Jacob story: to
his birth (Hos 12,4), to his wrestling with the divine being (12,4-5),
to his encounter with God at Bethel (12,5), to his time in Aram
(12,13). The reference to Jacob serving time in Aram for his wife
is followed directly by a reference to God bringing Israel out of
Egypt (12,14), in a poetic line that links back to the previous verse
through clever wordplay at the end of each line: ûbe’iššâ Å¡ÄmÄr
(12,13bβ) //ûbenÄbî’ niÅ¡mÄr (12,14b).
Micah too demonstrates fairly detailed familiarity with both the
exodus and the patriarchal stories. In Mic 6,4–5 we find reference
to the exodus, complete with the names of Moses, Aaron, and
Miriam, and to the Balaam episode. In Mic 7,15 the prophet asks
that God may “show us wondrous deeds as in the days when you
went out of Egypt†18. And at the end of the book, we read “You will
keep faith with Jacob, loyalty to Abraham, as you promised on oath
to our fathers in days gone by†(7,20).
In Jeremiah a very brief history of Israel is recounted, in Jer
32,20-23. It contains reference both to the exodus (“You freed your
people Israel from the land of Egyptâ€, 32,21) and to the promise to
the patriarchs (“You gave them this land that you had sworn to their
fathers to give themâ€, 32,22). The subsequent chapter of Jeremiah
again makes reference to the patriarchs, this time by name: “I will
never fail to take from [David’s] offspring rulers for the descen-
dants of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob†(Jer 33,26).
Emending the Hebrew ’ar’ennû to har’ēnû to better fit the sense of the
18
passage.
© Gregorian Biblical Press 2012 - Tutti i diritti riservati