Hans Ausloos - Valérie Kabergs, «Paronomasia or Wordplay? A Babel-Like Confusion. Towards a Definition of Hebrew Wordplay», Vol. 93 (2012) 1-20
Against the general background of a terminological confusion that is present in contributions about Hebrew wordplay, the definition of the socalled paronomasia in relation to the term wordplay is especially debated. This article aims to clarify the concept of wordplay in the Hebrew Bible. After a survey of the current opinions in defining the terms «paronomasia» and «wordplay» (I), we propose our own definition of «Hebrew wordplay» (II). Thereafter, this description will simultaneously delimit the field of Hebrew wordplay as it excludes a few linguistic figures, although they are possibly classified as wordplay in other studies (III).
8 VALÉRIE KABERGS – HANS AUSLOOS
Casanowicz Cherry V.K.
umbrella term for all umbrella term for: one particular way to
kinds of figures of “visual paronomasia†constitute a Hebrew
sound “oral paronomasia†wordplay: a combi-
(alliteration, asso- (= Casanowicz’s under- nation of words shar-
nance, other kinds of standing of paronomasia) ing a similar sound,
paronomasia rhyme, wordplay) “sense paronomasiaâ€20 but having a different
meaning (cf. the most
common classical
definition)
one specific type of synonym for Cherry’s umbrella term for a
paronomasia: i.e. a use of the concept (combination of)
sense-paronomasia paronomasia word(s) that play(s)
which consists of sim- on both sound and
wordplay ilar-sounding words meaning
also incorporating a
play on meaning
II. Towards A Definition
Against the backdrop of the above remarks about the termino-
logical confusion that is present in studies on wordplay since (and
also before) Casanowicz, we now aim at proposing our own en-
compassing definition of Hebrew wordplay. Two elements seem to
be especially important when speaking about Hebrew wordplay.
Constitutive for Hebrew wordplay is its ambiguous nature within a
specific literary context (1). This ambiguity is created by means of
a play between both the sound and the meaning of words (2), which
is moreover characteristic of the Hebrew language.
20
According to Cherry, “sense paronomasia†is a particular type of paro-
nomasia that creates ambiguity on the basis of lexical choices. The sound of
words does not play any role in this type. Cf. CHERRY, Paronomasia and Pro-
per Names in the Old Testament, 20-34. It has to be remarked that Casano-
wicz uses the term “sense-paronomasia†in a different way, i.e. as referring
to a play on both the sound (already implicated in his use of the term “paro-
nomasiaâ€) and meaning (“senseâ€).