J. Duncan - M. Derrett, «Ἔνοχος (Mt 5, 21-22) and the Jurisprudence of Heaven.», Vol. 19 (2006) 89-97
Besides the normal meaning, ἔνοχος has special dimension in the Sermon
on the Mount. Unaware of this commentators missed a great opportunity.
J. Duncan M. Derrett
92
To “enter the Kingdom of Heaven†one must be “free†by Heaven’s laws,
not merely man’s18.
3. The Antitheses
The so-called Antitheses are preceded by Mt 5,17-20, of which they are
collectively illustrations. The Scribes and the Pharisees who necessarily
depended on the former can only work on the Torah of Moses, the
prophets, and in the case of the Pharisees their “oral lawsâ€. The information
contained in b. Baba Mei῾a 30b and 83a repeated by C.G. Montefiore19
is along similar lines to our maxim, but it too relies on biblical texts, and
not the court(s) of Heaven. The fact was that one sought one’s answer
in whatever portions of scripture were relevant, and when these failed
turned to the Jurisprudence of Heaven, which, being controversial, might
not always be convincing! Jesus, it seems, knew better.
(1) Slaying
ΚÏίσις at 5,21,22 implies that two kinds of judgement are equal in
reality. Anger (with or without cause) is judged in the court of Heaven;
no less a συνέδÏιον than the earthly one, and the sentence may be to
Gêhînom, even though the words spoken are trivial and customary. The
urgency of the situation is emphasised. The court of Heaven does not
delay, unlike earthly courts which can be prorogued or influenced. One
cannot anticipate its judgement nor evade its sentence by making an
offering to the President personally! If you have an opponent who should
be appeased your case is down for hearing in the heavenly court. Get him
to withdraw his case. Even if he dies suddenly the case does not drop: the
court’s sentence is perfect in equity and in execution (which is at least as
important).
(2) Adultery
The Pentateuchal injunction (Ex 20, 14; Dt 5, 18) is inadequate, being
mechanical. The heart and mind are what count. Preparations are as
guilty as acts. This is a paradigm for other crimes, like theft and bribery.
Nature induces one to incur guilt. Rather (profit is humorously alluded
to συμφέÏει) amputate the offending limb and escape the sentence to
Gêhînom. Jesus does allude (5,22) to an everlasting (Is 66,24; Mk 9,43.48)20
Mt 5,20. Cf. 1Cor 6,9-10. Note μέθυσοι, λοίδοÏοι, á¼…Ïπαγες, such as might often
18
escape human justice.
C.G. Montefiore The Synoptic Gospels (London 1909) II, 500. Ex 18,20; Prov 2,20.
19
SB IV/2 (1924, 1969) 1036-7, 1093-6, 1100-02.
20