Andrew M. Bowden, «The Fruit of Righteousness in James: A Study in Discourse Analysis.», Vol. 26 (2013) 87-108
In this study, a discourse analysis of James is conducted with the goal of better understanding the structure, theme, and cohesion of the letter. By paying careful attention to the details of the text, James’ paragraphs are identified, as are the signals of transition between the various paragraphs. The conclusions reached based on a discourse analysis of James are illuminating. Far from being a randomly arranged work, James repeatedly uses present prohibitory imperatives in the overall organization of the Epistle. These imperatives are important in marking transitions between main sections. Furthermore, a discourse analysis reveals that James is a coherent epistle comprised of 16 paragraphs, with 3,13-18 providing the overarching macrostructure of the letter. Bearing the fruit of righteousness, a theme prominent in 3,13-18, is seen to be the letter’s overarching and unifying thought.
108 Andrew M. Bowden
macro-structure is identified by noting 1) that the language of this
paragraph relates directly with each section of the letter; 2) that the
prophetic allusions throughout the Epistle find their culmination in 3,13-
18; and 3) that the radical change of tone in 4,1 points to 3,13-18 as the
hinge upon which the letter turns.
Such an understanding of James’ flow and argument also enables
the reader to recognize the Epistle’s remarkable parallelism, which is
evident between James’ first and third sections (2,1-26; 4,11 – 5,8) and
between the introduction and conclusion. This parallelism explains the
numerous studies that organize James based on an inclusio (e.g., Taylor
and Guthrie), and those who argue for various levels of chiasm between
these units or the letter as a whole. Ultimately, discourse analysis shows
James to be a coherent epistle calling the readers to repentance for their
failure to bear the fruit of righteousness.
Andrew M. BOWDEN
Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
Sondermeierstraße 86
80939 München
Deutschland
andrewbowden40@yahoo.com