Andrew M. Bowden, «The Fruit of Righteousness in James: A Study in Discourse Analysis.», Vol. 26 (2013) 87-108
In this study, a discourse analysis of James is conducted with the goal of better understanding the structure, theme, and cohesion of the letter. By paying careful attention to the details of the text, James’ paragraphs are identified, as are the signals of transition between the various paragraphs. The conclusions reached based on a discourse analysis of James are illuminating. Far from being a randomly arranged work, James repeatedly uses present prohibitory imperatives in the overall organization of the Epistle. These imperatives are important in marking transitions between main sections. Furthermore, a discourse analysis reveals that James is a coherent epistle comprised of 16 paragraphs, with 3,13-18 providing the overarching macrostructure of the letter. Bearing the fruit of righteousness, a theme prominent in 3,13-18, is seen to be the letter’s overarching and unifying thought.
The Fruit of Righteousness in James: A Study in Discourse Analysis 95
firstfruits means: (1) being quick to hear (God’s word)31. Being quick to
hear entails slowness of speech and slowness of anger — both of which
foster the proper hearing of the word. (2) Living as God’s firstfruits means
receiving the word with gentleness (v. 21) — a certain humbleness of mind
and of demeanor. Receiving the word in this way involves putting off all
moral filth and the abundance of wickedness — yet another reminder
that the readers have sin, and lots of it, needing to be dealt with. They
are reminded that putting off sin is a healthy practice for believers and
ensures that they continue receiving the word in the proper manner, since
it is difficult to become arrogant when filth is being exposed through the
word (1,21). Thus, as believers continue dealing with sin, they continue
to receive the word with gentleness. (3) Living as God’s firstfruits means
not only hearing but also doing the word (vv. 22-25). James provides
an example of what it means to be a doer by alluding to a mirror (vv.
23-25). This paragraph concludes in the indicative (1,26-27), providing
a smooth ending to the body-introduction. Significantly, Verseput notes
that vv. 26-27 strongly allude to the prophetic material, since the Hebrew
prophets demanded the cessation of improper behavior and commanded
for the people to “defend the cause of the fatherless, plead the case of the
widow” (e.g., Isa 1,15-17)32.
In summary, we noted that vv. 2-27 function as the body-introduction
and are structured into three paragraphs: vv. 2-12, vv. 13-18, and vv.
19-27. In the first, believers are admonished to turn to God in prayer
when temptation reveals they are lacking so that they may be given the
wisdom which makes them τέλειοι. Secondly, James argues that believers
have no excuse for their lack because God has birthed them through his
word to live as his firstfruits. Finally, vv. 19-27 describe some of the fruit
produced by God’s offspring.
2.2.2 Body Proper (2,1 – 5,8)
Important to a discussion of James’s composition is an analysis of
the three large sections of the body: 2,1-26, 3,1 – 4,10, and 4,11 – 5,8.
An attempt will now be made to demonstrate that the body-proper is
composed of three sections whose peak is located in 3,13-18. Each of these
31
That this instruction is related to hearing God’s word, and not hearing in general,
is confirmed by 1,18, which speaks of the word by which believers were birthed, and by
1,21, which speaks of the implanted word that saves the soul. Such a view is supported by
Verseput (“Anger”, 432).
32
Verseput argues that vv. 26-27 offers a weighty climax to what goes before (“Anger”,
437), and then summarizes James’ thought: “True worship, he tells his readers, was to offer
to God with hands unstained by strife the righteous deeds of which the prophets had spoken”
(p. 439). Thus, pure and undefiled worship is the obedience required by the prophets.